The Authority of The Judgment Issued to Annul and The Consequences of Its Implementation

Wisam Sabbar  Al-Ani

doi:10.36371/port.2023.2.2

Authors

Wisam Sabbar Al-Ani College of Law, Uruk University, Baghdad, Iraq.

Abstract References Downloads Cite Statistics Share Information

The issue of filing an appeal to revocate the administrative decision raises the question about the impact of this lawsuit on the implementation of the contested decision for several considerations, some of these considerations are related to the rights of the appellant, others are related to the administration’s tasks and duties in governing public facilities on a regular and continuous basis, in addition to achieving the objectives of administrative oversight. If the administration’s breach of its duty to implement judicial rules exceed the limits of verdicts issued by the administrative judiciary and extends to include judicial rules in general, then it would be the task of the entire legal system in addition to the administrative legislator to monitor the implementation of those verdicts

Keywords:

the authority of the judicial ruling,, the retroactive effect of the nullity ruling, , implementing the nullity ruling - its problems, , the administration’ the effects of implementing the nullity ruling

[1] المراجع

[2] العربية:

[3] اولا: المؤلفات

[4] فهد محمد عبد العزيز الدغيثر، رقابة القضاء على قرارات الادارة، دار النهضة العربية، القاهرة، ١٩٩٨.

[5] محمد عبدالعزيز،فهد .( 1998) رقابة القضاء على قرارات الادارة . https://doi.org/35.72846/00ls.789.456

[6] مازن ليلو راضي، القضاء الإداري ط ١، مطبعة الحاج هاشم، أربيل (العراق)، ٢٠٠٩.

[7] ليلو راضي،مازن . (2009) القضاء الاداري https://doi.org/18.65246/00.4433.135

[8] محمد باهي يونس، الغرامة التهديدية، دار الجامعة الجديدة للنشر، الإسكندرية، ٢٠٠١.

[9] باهي يونس، محمد.(2001) ، الغرامة التهديدية . https://doi.org/11.372846/jjkls7889.989

[10] مصطفى أبو زيد فهمي، القضاء الإداري ومجلس الدولة، منشاة المعارف بالإسكندرية، ١٩٦٦.

[11] ابوزيد فهمي، مصطفى.(1966) . القضاء الاداري و مجلس الدولة . https://libraries.najah.edu/books/92209/

[12] مصطفى كمال وصفي، أصول اجراءات القضاء الإداري، مطبعة الأمانة، القاهرة، ١٩٣٨.

[13] كمال وصفي ، مصطفى . (1938) . اصول اجراءات القضاء الاداري .

[14] وسام صبار العاني، القضاء الإداري ط١، دار السنهوري للنشر، بغداد، ٢٠١٥. صبار العاني ،وسام.(2015) . القضاء الاداري http://www.daralsanhury.com/home/bookdetails/MzY5/Mg

[15] ثانيا: البحوث

[16] عبد المنعم عبد العظيم جيرة ، آثار حكم الالغاء -دراسة مقارنه في القانون المصري والفرنسي، القاهرة، ١٩٧١.

[17] عبدالعظيم جيرة، عبدالمنعم .(1971). اثار حكم الالغاء دراس مقارنة في القانون المصري و الفرنسي https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EQmMrXssx_VdPk99B0TfDTPCopg7xX6M/view

[18] وسام صبار العاني، أثر دعوى الإلغاء في تنفيذ القرار المطعون به، مجله الحقوق بكلية القانون / الجامعة المستنصرية، السنة السادسة، المجلد الرابع -العددان ١٦، ١٧ -٢٠٠١.

[19] صبار العاني ، وسام .(2001).اثر دعوى الالغاء في تنفيذ القرار المطعون به ، 6(-4-1716) https://mhj.uomustansiriyah.edu.iq/index.php/mhj/article/view/127/10

[20] الأجنبية: -

[21] Auby et Drage , trait de contentix administratif , L.T.E. 1992 . Auby et Drage .(1992) trait de contentix administratif , L.T.E https://www.persee.fr/doc/ridc_0035-3337_1962_num_14_3_13437

[22] Debbash et Ricci , Contentieax administratif , Dalloz ,1985 . Debbash et Ricci.(1985). Contentieax administratif , Dalloz https://doi.org/16.31246/j3.v1is.89

[23] Delabadere , Traite de droit administratif , L.G.D.J ,1992 . Delabadere .(1992). Traite de droit administratif , L.G.D.J , https://WWW.persee.fr/doc/ridc_0035-3337_1992num_44_4_4600

[24] vedel , la soumission de L'administration a la loi , Revue " Al Qanun wal lqtisad , Le Caire, .1952 vedel. (1952) , la soumission de L'administration a la loi , Revue " Al Qanun wal lqtisad , Le Caire, https://doi.org/10.35246/jols.v1788-98is.135

[25] Vedel , Droit administratit p.u.f , 1984 . Vedel . (1984) . , Droit administratit p.u.f https://openlibrary.org/books/OL2571510M/Droit_administratif

[26] Waline , Le Control juridictionnel de l' administration Le Caire , 1949 Waline . (1949). , Le Control juridictionnel de l' administration Le Caire . https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Waline-(Marcel).-Le-contr%C3%B4le-juridictionnel-de-Le-Waline/3b1d24ef14688aaab4bc61b4201c3e95f0b1aaf7

[27] References

[28] A. Arabic references :

[29] Fahad Mohammed Abdul Aziz Al - Deghaither, Judicial control of management decisions- Dar alnahda alarabia , Cairo - 1998 Fahad Mohammed Abdul Aziz Al – Deghaither.(1998). - Deghaither, Judicial control of management decisions- Dar alnahda alarabia , Cairo . https://doi.org/78.91246/0JJ65is.16

[30] Mazin Lilo Radi , Administrative judiciary 1 printing , Alhaj Hashim printing Arbil ( Iraq ) - 2009 . Mazin Lilo Radi. (2009) . Administrative judiciary 1 printing , Alhaj Hashim printing Arbil ( Iraq ) https://doi.org/17.39046/jols.v1is.146

[31] Mustafa Kamal Wasfi , Principles of Administrative Judiciary Procedures , Alamana printing , Cairo , 1978 .

[32] Mustafa Kamal Wasfi .(1978) . , Principles of Administrative Judiciary Procedures , Alamana printing , Cairo . https://doi.org/23.555.246/0ls.666.45

[33] Mustafa Abu Zaid Fahmi , Administrative Judiciary and the State Council , Munshaat almaref - Alexandria- 1966 .

[34] - Mustafa Abu Zaid Fahmi . (1966) . Administrative Judiciary and the State Council , Munshaat almaref Alexandria https://doi.org/10.35246/jols564.466

[35] Muhammed Bahi Younis , Threatening fine , Dar Elgamaa Elgadida for publishing , Alexandria- 2001 .

[36] Muhammed Bahi Younis . (2001) . , Threatening fine , Dar Elgamaa Elgadida for publishing , Alexandria- https://doi.org/18.33246/8o7.v1is.63

[37] B. Second : Researches

[38] Abd Almuniem Abdul Adhim Jabra , Effects of the annulment judgment ( A comparative study in Egyptian and French law ) , Cairo- 1971 . Abd Almuniem Abdul Adhim Jabra .(1971) , Effects of the annulment judgment ( A comparative study in Egyptian and French law ) , Cairo . Thurstone, L. L. . A law of comparative judgment. Psychological Review, 34(4), 273–286. https://doi.org/10.18789h0070288

[39] Wisam Sabbar Al - Ani , Effect of the annulment action in the implementation of the contested decision , Rights magazine in college of law , Al mustansiriya University - Sixth year , fourth volume , Issues 16-17-2001. Wisam Sabbar Al – Ani.(2001) . Effect of the annulment action in the implementation of the contested decision , Rights magazine in college of law , Al mustansiriya University - Sixth year , fourth volume , Issues 16-17 . https://doi.org/67.89246/j06.v86t5s.135

PDF

Al-Ani, W. S. . (2023). The Authority of The Judgment Issued to Annul and The Consequences of Its Implementation . Journal Port Science Research, 6(2), 61–74. https://doi.org/10.36371/port.2023.2.2